Promotion? No, thanks

A young executive is invited into the boss’s room. The boss smiles, offers tea and announces, “Congratulations, you have been promoted.” The employee asks four questions: How much more will I earn? How many people will I manage? Will I have greater authority? And must I answer WhatsApp messages at midnight? By the fourth answer, congratulations sounds suspiciously like condolences.

For generations, promotion simply meant success. A larger title, a bigger office and a new line on the business card confirmed progress. Refusing a promotion was unthinkable. Today, more young employees are saying, “No, thanks.”

Tap here to add The Daily Star as a trusted source

Perhaps ambition has changed. Many now value skills over titles, wellbeing over visibility and sustainable achievement over theatre.

Deloitte’s 2026 global survey found that only 25 percent of Gen Z and 21 percent of millennials prefer rapid career progression through promotions. Most favour steady growth, while some are willing to move sideways or step back for experience. This is not the death of ambition. Some 76 percent of Gen Z respondents and 67 percent of millennials remain interested in senior leadership. They want leadership, but not this version.

What do they see? Managers caught between ambitious targets above and anxious employees below. Gartner reports that 47 percent of managers are working harder than a year earlier. They spend about nine hours a week addressing employees’ personal and emotional concerns, despite limited influence over pay, staffing or policy. The manager is expected to be a strategist, counsellor, firefighter and cheerleader.

In some companies, promotion brings a grander designation, a larger team, more meetings and a modest pay rise. In my last job, the salary adjustment was only 5 percent, while responsibility increased manifold. Authority remained with the owner or the boss’s boss. An Assistant General Manager becomes General Manager and discovers that the only thing removed from the job is the word “Assistant”.

Technology has made the burden clearer. Email once waited. WhatsApp has no such respect for office hours, weekends or family dinners. Instant replies signal commitment; pauses can look like a lack of it. Young employees watch this lifestyle and make a rational calculation. The ladder may still go upwards, but every step carries more weight.

Generations have rarely differed so sharply. A senior leader opens Excel, prepares PowerPoint and posts on Facebook, feeling modern; Gen Z considers all three museum pieces. Employers may mistake digital confidence for impatience, while younger employees mistake experience for obsolescence. Reverse mentoring must replace suspicion.

Companies promote technical performers into management without asking whether they can, or even want to, lead people. Gallup found that only 45 percent of frontline supervisors had received supervisory training in the previous year, while 23 percent had never received any. The younger generation is not entirely right. Leadership cannot become a permanent comfort zone. Greater responsibility requires difficult decisions, longer thinking and sacrifice. An organisation cannot build its future if everyone wants influence, but nobody accepts accountability.

However, companies must make promotions worth accepting. That means fair compensation, genuine authority, manageable teams, leadership training and protection from permanent availability. Technical specialists should have career paths that do not require becoming reluctant managers. Growth should have more than one path.

Senior leaders often complain that young people lack loyalty and ambition. Perhaps ambition has changed. Many now value skills over titles, wellbeing over visibility and sustainable achievement over theatre.

If the next generation refuses to climb, management should inspect the ladder before blaming the climbers. A promotion should recognise success and enable greater contribution. When “Congratulations” sounds like a punishment, the problem may not be the employee. It may be the promotion.

The writer is the founder of BuildCon Consultancies Ltd and BuildNation Ltd