Emiliano Martinez joins Chelsea: Is the Argentine really an upgrade on Robert Sanchez?

Chelsea have signed goalkeeper Emiliano “Dibu” Martínez from Aston Villa on a three-year deal, the West London club confirmed on Sunday, bringing the Argentina international to Stamford Bridge to challenge Robert Sanchez for the No. 1 spot.

Financial details were not disclosed, but British media reports put the fee at around £7.5 million for the 33-year-old.

Tap here to add The Daily Star as a trusted source

“I want to be successful here,” Martínez said in a statement. 

“I'm someone who wants to win at everything I do and I want to bring that here to this football club because it's a football club that wins titles, so I think it's a good match.”

Coming to Chelsea, for me and my family, was an easy decision to make and I’m just over the moon - I can’t wait to get started.

"Coming to Chelsea, for me and my family, was an easy decision to make and I’m just over the moon - I can’t wait to get started," he added.

The move raises a straightforward question: is Martínez actually a better goalkeeper than Sanchez, or simply a different type of goalkeeper?

Martínez's arrival comes after another difficult spell for Sanchez, whose latest problems surfaced in Chelsea's 3-2 win over Fulham.

Sanchez was beaten by Josh King's effort before parrying Timothy Castagne's shot into the path of Gonzalo Garcia. He also came out of his area at the wrong moment later in the game, nearly presenting Fulham with another chance.

Those incidents reinforced the concerns that have followed Sanchez throughout his Chelsea career: not necessarily a lack of ability, but inconsistency in decision-making.

The numbers do not show a huge difference in errors. Between the start of the 2023/24 season and the end of 2025/26, Sanchez made seven errors leading to goals in the Premier League, compared with six for Martínez. However, Martínez played around 20 more league matches and almost 1,700 more minutes during that period.

The bigger difference is in how the two goalkeepers operate.

Sanchez is comfortable playing from the back and can function as an extra passing option for a possession-heavy side. He is also capable of making difficult saves, particularly with his reflexes.

But his aggressive approach can also create problems. He has been prone to coming off his line at questionable moments, taking too long in possession and making mistakes that can unsettle the defence in front of him.

Martínez is also not a flawless goalkeeper. He can be aggressive, particularly when coming off his line, and his distribution is good rather than exceptional.

But his strengths are more closely aligned with what Chelsea appear to need at the moment.

Martínez spent six seasons at Villa Park after joining Aston Villa from Arsenal in 2020, making 256 appearances and establishing himself as one of the Premier League's leading goalkeepers.

He played a key role last season as Unai Emery's side finished fourth to qualify for the Champions League and won the Europa League. His departure was made possible after Villa signed Japan international Zion Suzuki from Parma earlier this month.

His biggest strength is arguably his performance in high-pressure situations.

Martínez is particularly strong in one-on-one situations and has repeatedly produced important saves in decisive moments. His most famous example remains his late save against Randal Kolo Muani in the 2022 World Cup final, but there have been plenty of important interventions for Villa since then.

His international pedigree is difficult to ignore, either. Martínez helped Argentina win the 2022 World Cup and the Copa América in 2021 and 2024, before finishing runners-up at the 2026 World Cup.

That experience matters for Chelsea.

The club are working with a new manager in Xabi Alonso and still have a young squad. They also have 21-year-old goalkeeper Mike Penders, who is regarded as a long-term option but is not necessarily ready to become Chelsea's undisputed Premier League No. 1.

Martínez therefore offers experience while Penders develops.

There is also a personality difference.

Martínez is vocal, demanding and comfortable taking responsibility. He has built a reputation for embracing pressure rather than avoiding it. That can be particularly valuable for a goalkeeper because his decisions affect the defensive line as much as his own performance.

Sanchez, meanwhile, has struggled to build that same level of confidence around him at Stamford Bridge.

That does not make Martínez a dramatically superior goalkeeper in every category. Sanchez is younger, has good technical ability and can still improve. But Chelsea are not signing Martínez simply because he can stop more shots.

They are signing a goalkeeper with six years of Premier League experience, international pedigree and a proven record of performing in high-pressure matches.

The comparison is therefore less about spectacular saves and more about reliability, decision-making and leadership.

Chelsea have already given Sanchez three seasons to establish himself.

Martínez arrives with a very different task: to make the position feel settled while Chelsea build under Alonso.

On that basis, the move looks like an upgrade. Not necessarily because Martínez is better at everything, but because his experience, personality and ability to deliver under pressure may address some of the very issues that have made Chelsea's goalkeeping position unsettled.